Every band has at least one song that will get a big reaction from the crowd. It doesn't matter how many amazing songs a band has recorded, the radio hits will always be the ones people are waiting to hear, and those hits will almost always be played at the end of the set.
A few bands transcend this problem. The Beatles or the Rolling Stones, for example, have enough instantly recognizable songs to vary the encore from night to night. Even so, when you're touring 200 cities in 250 days, things are probably going to get repetitious. I saw Bob Dylan play Pittsburgh in August and the final song of the set was "Like a Rolling Stone." He has to be tired of playing it.
And so, I'm forced to feel a bit sorry for working-class touring bands. There are quite a few bands that have had just one reasonably well-known hit. These bands are the ones that have to endure crowds full of people only familiar with that one song.
In a way, it's better than having no hit songs. People are coming to the show, the money's coming in and more hits are bound to come along sooner or later. Unfortunately, the music-listening public is fickle. The chances of scoring one recognizable song are pretty low, let alone the chances of it happening twice.
So bands like the Ataris, Augustana and Phantom Planet are forced to wade through show after show of audience members shouting "Boys of Summer!" or "Boston!" or "That song from The O.C.!" at every possible chance they get.
There are certainly more bands cursed with this albatross than the three I named, but I picked these specifically because they've recently played at Penn State.
Phantom Planet played at Movin' On in 2007. A good number of people complained that the group wasn't nearly high profile enough to be the headliner at the show, but I didn't have any real problem with the choice. Sure, there are hundreds of bands I'd probably have preferred, but I do enjoy Planet's albums from time to time.
Phantom Planet, tragically, recorded the song that went on to become the theme song ("California") for Fox's hit series The O.C. Movin' On is free and open to all students, so most of the people in attendance were familiar only with "California" despite the band's varied catalog of songs. The crowd took to shouting the song's title and variations thereof ("Play that one song from that show!") for the group's entire set.
Heckling the band you're watching is like kicking your disobedient dog. Things aren't going to get better. If you want to guarantee yourself a bad concert experience, work as hard as you can to destroy the band's self-confidence. You're sure to be rewarded.
The Ataris might have it the worst of all. This is a band with several quality records and a following that has an appreciation for many of those songs. Yet, when the Ataris recorded a cover of Don Henley's "Boys of Summer" and the record company forced the group to include the song on So Long, Astoria, everything changed. The Ataris practically became a household name, yet the only song anyone knew wasn't even originally by the band.
Kris Roe, the band's principle songwriter, got to see his own work overshadowed night after night by a cover song. Though the band has tried at times to avoid playing the song, it's what the fans want to hear. So when the Ataris stopped in State College last Sunday, "Boys of Summer" came too.
The next time you see a show, remember: there's no need to shout that one song's name every 30 seconds. It'll be there.
- Andrew