Kurt Bopp: This is not the Cole Hamels of last season, and in a tiny park, he's gong to struggle to keep the Yankees in the park. Meanwhile, Andy Pettite is experienced and consistent. Pettite wins his first World Series start since his loss to Josh Beckett in 2003.
Yankees 7 Phillies 3
Dan Rorabugh: The Phillies haven't had the kind of year they expected from Cole Hamels, and Andy Pettitte certainly has the postseason pedigree to claim the edge in this one. But the offense headed by Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Shane Victorino and Jayson Werth won't put up just one run two games in a row. And the Yankee bats haven't exactly been white hot so far in this series.
Phillies 5 Yankees 3
Dave Rung: Facing perhaps the best postseason pitcher ever in Andy Pettitte, Cole Hamels will return to his 2008 playoff form and give the Phillies seven solid innings. Game 1 hero Chase Utley and overall playoff hero Ryan Howard will provide the offense in a Philadelphia win.
Phillies 5 Yankees 2
Zack Feldman: Back at home, the Phillies know they need this game to retain any chance at a pennant (especially with Blanton starting Game 4). It will come down to the bullpens, but the Phillies will pull this one out.
Phillies 5 Yankees 4
Andrew J. Cassavell: I'll be donning my pinstripes in section 318 for what should be the swing game of the series. Tonight's winning manager gets flexibility with his pitching staff, while the loser has to scramble just to make it a series again. I'm going with big-game Andy to bring back memories of game 5 in '96 and game 4 in '98.
Yanks 5 Phils 1
Allison Rainsford: Cole Hamels will finally return to 2008 form in front of a hyped up crowd and go 7 innings strong, giving up only one long ball. The Phils will once again contain A-Rod and get their offense going, racking up some early inning runs. And Brad Lidge will save another postseason game.
Phillies 5 Yankees 2
Stephen Hennessey: At the beginning of the series, many analysts thought the performance of A.J. Burnett and Cole Hamels would be the biggest key to victory. Burnett stepped up to the plate in Game 2, now it's Hamels time to prove himself. Yet, I think it will be Andy Pettitte who is the one to seize the moment for his team.
Yanks 6 Phillies 4







Leave a comment