The new editor in chief of the Penn State University Press is faced with tenure-seeking professors clamoring for publication, librarians nationwide who can't afford to buy his books and an industry in major upheaval.
While professors at universities across the country are trying to publish works to achieve tenured positions, many university presses are facing monetary pressures that keep them from publishing at a higher rate.
"Things like tenure requirements keep going up, and universities demand that professors publish monographs [scholarly texts]," Patrick Alexander, editor in chief, said. "And yet it becomes increasingly expensive to publish monographs."
Penn State literature professor Michael Bérubé helped draft a Modern Language Association (MLA) report last year addressing the scarcity of publishing options open to tenure-bound professors. Most liberal arts institutions require professors to present published works to gain tenure.
Although the supply of prospective publications has skyrocketed, press directors say the demand for their purchase has plummeted as cash-strapped libraries are making do with fewer new books every year. Holly Carver, director of the University of Iowa Press, cited decreased library sales and increasing pressure from wholesalers as the greatest fiscal challenges in a "increasingly challenging and competitive marketplace."
Leary said while her press might have sold 2,000 copies of a monograph years ago, they may now only sell 600.
"[Libraries] just don't need very many in print form because of a lot of changes," she said. "In classes, instead of assigning a lot of books, professors might be more likely now to put things on electronic reserve."
Bérubé said in January that the publishing requirement has placed an extraordinary burden on university presses, which are receiving more submissions for publication than their budgets can afford.
"The book standard is creeping all over places where it doesn't belong," he said.
Sheila Leary, director of the University of Wisconsin Press, agreed.
"There have been some articles written about the curiosity of the system that academic departments are relying on presses to make tenure decisions for them," she said.
Alexander said the problem lies in traditional models of publishing becoming more outdated.
"I think the most pressing challenge facing Penn State or any university publisher is the changing face of scholarly communications and the rising costs associated with that," Alexander said. "I think old models for publishing are becoming increasingly not viable, [and] it's up to the scholarly community to come up with some new models for publishing."

