What baffled me most about the Collegian editor in chief's response to Phroth's latest edition of The Phaily Phollegian was her blatant disregard for Phroth itself. She calls us simply "a group of students." OK, so maybe we don't work for the Collegian and because you do you consider any other student publication beneath you. But don't for one minute discount the amount of effort and dedication our club (that's right, Phroth is a recognized Penn State "club") puts into every article, every issue. Maybe the Collegian's apparent lack of a sense of humor is the reason most of us chose to write for and work with Phroth rather than the Collegian. And yes, I am a dues paying club member.