One would think that a book studied for more than 150 years would be unable to hide anything from its readers, but a Penn State professor has proved this idea wrong.
Richard Kopley, an associate professor of English at Penn State's Dubois Campus, was working on his Edgar Allan Poe research when he came across an unfamiliar poem that Poe had reviewed in a literary magazine. The poem, "A Legend of Brittany," struck Kopley as something he had read before in Nathaniel Hawthorne's The Scarlet Letter. Little did he know this connection would later result in his first scholarly book.
"For many years, I taught the correlation between Poe's The Tell-Tale Heart and The Scarlet Letter in my American literature classes, but I never sought out other allusions," Kopley said. "When I came across 'A Legend of Brittany,' I was very excited to explore this other connection."
Upon researching, Kopley came across another book that seemed to show the same linking potential. The Salem Belle: A Tale of 1692, written by an anonymous author seven years beforehand, had a strikingly similar climax to that of The Scarlet Letter, in which a stirring monologue is given to an accusatory and malevolent crowd. There were also many other connections between the two texts, such as a strange mentioning of scaffolding in the monologues.
"Once I came across The Salem Belle: A Tale of 1692 and discovered that Hawthorne would have most likely read it, my next question was why he chose to allude to it in The Scarlet Letter," Kopley said.

