The Digital Collegian - Published independently by students at Penn State
NEWS
[ Monday, Nov. 10, 2003 ]

PSU students react to deal with Napster

For The Collegian

With the agreement between Penn State and Napster officially sealed, students soon will be able to stream music legally for free.

But not all students are sold on the idea.

Although the cost is included in each student's $160 information technology fee, not every student will be able to access the new service, because it can only be used on Windows 98, 2000 and XP.

Karen Bodnar (junior-accounting) said Napster should be included in the technology fee if there are no other uses for funds.

"It's good to protect students, but I don't know if it will float so well [with everyone]," she said.

What do you think of the new Napster program?

"I think it's good to protect students, but I don't know if it will float so well [with everyone]."

Karen Bodna
(junior - accounting)

"I think it's a good step in the right direction. It's a good idea but not a full solution."

Mike Lahm
(junior - computer science)

"It's a good deal for students who want to download music but don't want to get in trouble. I will still use programs like Kazaa because I want to burn songs onto a CD."

Laura Armann
(freshman - advertising)

"With the record companies cracking down, it's a nice way for students to download music for free. Students should have to pay for burned CDs."

Rob Newmiller
(sophomore - finance)

"I'd rather be able to download and burn CDs. It bothers me that I will pay because I won't use it."

Jacquelyn Virgi
(junior - biology)

"My computer is not compatible. I have Windows ME. I think it is kind of dumb."

Amy Paliwoda
(junior - advertising)


The new service may not go over well with Macintosh and Windows Millennium Edition (ME) users, some of whom feel they were overlooked by the university.

Amy Paliwoda (junior-advertising), who uses Windows ME, said, "My computer is not compatible. I think it is kind of dumb."

Marcelo Molina (sophomore-computer science and business), a Mac user, opposes the new deal with Napster.

"I doubt Apple will ever work with Napster," he said. "Most likely I'll never [be able to] use it."

He added that the university should have asked students what service to use first.

He feels Apple's iTunes would have been a better choice because it works for both Windows and Macs. iTunes is available, however, to students on an individual basis.

Although the Napster service will be available in the spring to students who live on campus, it will not be available to students living off campus until next fall.

Some students who live off campus are not bothered by the wait.

Rob Newmiller (sophomore-finance) said he is willing to wait longer to obtain music legally.

"With the record companies cracking down, it's a nice way for students to download music for free," he said.

But some students are skeptical of another limitation -- burning music onto CDs.

The new service will require students to pay a fee of 99 cents to permanently obtain a song.

The Napster service provides streaming music for free, but will limit the amount of users the music can be shared with.

"It's just renting music," Molina said of the Napster program, due to its limitations.

Some students are clinging on to peer-to-peer programs like Kazaa because it allows music to be downloaded permanently for free, even though it would be considered illegal by Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) standards.

Laura Armann (freshman-advertising) is one of these students.

"It's a good deal for students who want to download music but don't want to get in trouble," she said. "I will still use programs like Kazaa because I want to burn songs onto a CD."

Jacquelyn Virgi (junior-biology) agreed, saying, "I'd rather be able to download and burn CDs. It bothers me that I will pay [for Napster] because I won't use it."

Mike Lahm (junior- computer science) is optimistic about the new service, but feels there's always room for improvement.

"I think it's a good step in the right direction," he said. "It's a good idea but not a full solution."




R E L A T E D  S T O R Y
 



TOP  HOME
Blogs  About  Contact Us  Back Issues  Advertising 

Copyright © 2009 Collegian Inc.