The majority of the crowd dispersed by 3 a.m. But with officers still deployed at 5 a.m., the riot had turned into an all-night affair.
And more than two weeks later it still hasn't ended.
Last week, police Chief Tom King spent most of his workdays in meetings discussing the riots.
Cpl. Rick Ososkie lost a week out of his schedule ordering replacement equipment.
Other officers have spent time watching more than 15 hours of videotape from the riots, gathering original and additional evidence and documenting where it is on the tape.
Still, another officer pulls pictures off the tapes to place on the department's Web site.
They have also been fielding telephone calls from community members, students and parents.
All of this contributes to the amount of time each officer spends at work, which translates into money.
"These things cost of a lot of money," said Borough Manager Peter Marshall. "We've probably spent between $15,000 and $20,000 just for one night."
Penn State Police Services is also feeling the riot's after effects. They, too, are busy with cleaning and repairing equipment, filling out paperwork, attending court sessions and helping the State College police, said Penn State officer Carrie Gratzmiller.
The State College police has made an effort to include members of the Undergraduate Student Government to discuss riot prevention.
USG Director of Town Affairs Darren Robertson said he and USG President Matt Roan sat in on riot prevention committee meetings.
Students and police have continued to debate about some of the logistics of the riot, such as the order to disperse given on the night of the riot. Students said the order wasn't given clearly enough and they didn't know they had to leave. Police officers said they gave plenty of warning.
"We were scratching our heads as to why people think they have a right to engage in this type of behavior and not obey an official police officer," Conrad said.
"I think we have a different perspective than they do. This is our job. We're professional about it."
At Penn State, the riot only escalated to the use of pepper spray.
In a riot last Monday at the University of Arizona, police used stun grenades, rubber bullets and tear gas to control students who reacted to their basketball team's championship defeat by taking to the streets and burning cars.
Conrad said there's a progressing use of force continuum used by police across the country.
"If our presence and our verbal warnings aren't working then we escalate to the next level and the next level is pepper spray," Conrad said.
Robertson wants police to have a better way to alert students that the order to disperse has been given.
"For our own safety, we have to come up with a clear way to make the order known," Robertson said. He mentioned using some sort of signal, siren or announcement that everyone could agree on and recognize.
"Now we have to seriously come up with solutions. There needs to be a community-wide effort to come up with a solution.
"There needs to be a rebuilding of trust between the police, community members and students."
Conrad agreed.
"We ask people to think about this. This is the only way it's going to change. We don't have the ability to change people's minds. They have to become responsible."
Coming tomorrow: How riots hurt local businesses.