Collegian Venues - your weekend starts here
  Collegian Chronicles



Get a deal with Daily Collegian Coupon Corner
  The Digital Collegian - Published independently by students at Penn State
NEWS
[ Tuesday, Jan. 30, 2001 ]

Emel sentenced for DUI homicide
The man responsible for last year's alcohol-related death of Kim Fisher received four to eight years in state prison.

Collegian Staff Writer

BELLEFONTE — Scott A. Emel, the 22-year-old man responsible for last January's death of Penn State librarian Kim Fisher, was sentenced yesterday to four to eight years in state prison and fined for reckless driving offenses.

Emel was convicted Jan. 10 on a charge of homicide while driving under the influence and on two additional counts of DUI. Emel was also found guilty of two summary offenses related to reckless driving.

Assistant District Attorney Stephen Sloane said he would push for a maximum sentence of five to 10 years incarceration.

In discussions prior to the sentencing, Assistant District Attorney Lance Marshall explained to Judge Tom Kistler why he felt the maximum sentence should be applied in Emel's case.

Barbara Ovrutsky
PHOTO: Barbara Ovrutsky
Scott A. Emel is led out of the Bellefonte courthouse after his sentencing.

"The worst thing that could happen in this case is that the sentence doesn't reflect what the defendant has done from age 16 to 20," Marshall said. ". . .Drinking and numerous driving offenses . . . sooner or later, these two things were going to be combined and tragedy would happen."

Marshall discussed some of Emel's past offenses, including Emel's March arrest for possession of cocaine and drug paraphernalia.

The drug arrest occurred three months after Emel killed Fisher.

"If Emel isn't eligible for the statutory maximum sentence . . . then nobody is," Marshall said.

Emel's attorney, Joseph Amendola, asked Judge Kistler to consider a combination of rehabilitation and prison time for Emel.

"Yes, Emel will be thrown in with rapists, armed robbers . . . but I dare say, I don't know how that will help his rehabilitation," Amendola said.

Amendola said the death of Fisher was a sufficient "wake-up call" for Emel.

But Marshall argued that Emel was still decisively negligent, even after killing Fisher.

"The wake up call, if any, was after he was caught drinking the second time — and with cocaine in the hotel room," Marshall said. "A long prison sentence will speak volumes for Mr. Emel."

After arguments from both attorneys, Emel spoke to the judge and court, describing his remorse for his actions that led to and followed Fisher's death last Jan. 7.

"I apologize to the court and apologize to anyone who knows or is related to Mr. Fisher," Emel said. "For what it's worth . . . I'm sorry."

Kistler said Emel was not an eligible candidate for boot camp because it could interfere with the mandatory legislative sentence for homicide while driving under the influence.

"It is clearly evident to me that this is a pattern.

This was not a momentary lapse of judgment," Kistler said.

Emel has 30 days to appeal the sentence. Amendola said an appeal has not yet been discussed with Emel and his family.

Emel and several local businesses, including Damon's Restaurant, 1031 E. College Ave., were charged in a wrongful death suit filed by Fisher's sister, Carla Manley.

The suit claims that the co-defendants, who served Emel alcohol, are partially responsible for the driving accident that killed Fisher.

 

Send an Opinion Letter to the Editor about this article.


   





TOP  HOME
Blogs  About  Contact Us  Back Issues  Advertising 

Copyright © 2008 Collegian Inc.
Updated: Tuesday, January 30, 2001  1:22:57 AM  -4
Requested: Friday, July 25, 2008  4:03:45 PM  -4
Created: Wednesday, May 07, 2008  6:32:21 PM  -4