Four out of the six Penn State competitors counted falls on the beam, leading the Lions to a 47.300 on the event, the only event in which the Wildcats would beat the Nittany Lions.
"We were a little nervous on beam and we made some mistakes," Penn State women's gymnastics coach Steve Shephard said.
"We weren't quite as sharp tonight as we were against Illinois. We have the potential to do a lot better."
Penn State's Maria Taylor came through for her team though, finishing the rotation on beam and scoring a 9.825, which would earn her a first place finish on the beam and tied New Hampshire's Suzanne Poretz.
Taylor stepped up her performance in more than one way this weekend. In addition to her finish on beam, she also placed first on bars earning a 9.925.
Taylor's contributions to the team earned her the Ann Carr Award, which is given to the gymnast who provides the most inspirational performance at each home meet.
Penn State made up for its poor performance on beam with solid performances on bars, vault and floor.
The Nittany Lions scored a 49.350 on bars, 48.550 on vault and a 48.875 on floor and took first, second and third place on all three of the events.