Collegian Chronicles

digital collegian
Wednesday, March 18, 1998

HUB shooting trial still on hold

A year and a half after fatal shooting, legal complications have kept the trial process stalled.

By JENNIFER NEJMAN
Collegian Staff Writer

Although yesterday marked the 18-month anniversary of a shooting that resulted in the death of one University student, the person charged with the shooting, Jillian Robbins, has not yet gone to trial.

story link logo
Sniper kills student on HUB lawn, Collegian Article - 9/17/96
One reason Robbins of State College has not gone to trial is because of the defense of insanity, said Centre County District Attorney Ray Gricar. The-year-and-a-half waiting period for an insanity case is not unusual, he added.

"I feel confident the case will come to trial before the end of the year," Gricar said, "but it's hard to guess which month it will be in."

Robbins, then 19, was charged with one count of first-degree murder, one count of third-degree murder, five counts of attempted murder and five counts of aggravated assault for the Sept. 17, 1996, shooting on the HUB Lawn. Gricar is seeking the death penalty.

"The Commonwealth (of Pennsylvania) hates to be in a situation when a case takes so long to bring to trial," Gricar said, "but there's simply nothing else to be done to speed things up."

story link logo
DA files charges against Robbins, Collegian Article - 9/19/96
Court actions were also delayed because Robbins was hospitalized for nine months at the Norristown State Hospital in October 1996. As a result, a pending hearing on the defense's motion to move the case to another county was canceled.

Robbins has since been released from the hospital and is currently in Clinton County Prison. Centre County does not have a facility for female inmates, said Deborah Lux, first assistant to the public defender.

After the defense completes a review process consisting of records of Robbins' past evaluations and history, the prosecution will appoint a doctor to review Robbins past, Gricar said.

Once the review process is completed, the court will schedule various pretrial motions, Gricar said.

"There hasn't been any court hearing on the case since preliminary hearings," Gricar said, which took place Sept. 26, 1996.

story link logo
Jillian Robbins' arraignment Collegian Article - 9/23/96
Robbins, of 240-204 Turtle Creek Apartments, 358 Toftrees Ave., was arrested at the scene after she had allegedly fired five rounds of artillery from a 7mm Mauser rifle at pedestrians. Brendon Malovrh, Class of 1997, disarmed Robbins.

One bullet resulted in the death of 21-year-old University student Melanie Spalla of Altoona while another hit and wounded 23-year-old student Nicholas Mensah of Philadelphia.

go to home page Copyright © 1998, Collegian Inc., Last Updated - 3/18/98 6:15:52 PM